Buy the Dip?: Herbert, Ohtani and 7 more
How this works
Every card here dropped in the last four weeks while the overall card market slipped only about 3%. The reason behind the drop is the point. Whether it's a buying chance is your call.
- Before: the typical PSA 10 price from Sept 7 to Oct 11.
- Now: the typical PSA 10 price from Oct 12 to Nov 8.
- Last week: the typical price of the most recent sales, to show which way it's heading.
NFL
Justin Herbert, 2020 Donruss Optic Holo #153
- Before: $185
- Now: $154 (−17%)
- Last week: $170
The Chargers are 0–8. Herbert was sacked a career-high eight times in a 44–22 loss to Houston on Nov 8 and left with a left middle-finger injury. X-rays came back negative, and Jim Harbaugh says he should be good to go for the Ravens on Monday night.
Cam Ward, 2025 Donruss Downtown! #12
- Before: $721
- Now: $530 (−26%)
- Last week: $522
The Titans are 1–7 at the bye and just traded Jeffery Simmons to Chicago. Ward's best game yet came Nov 1, with 304 yards and 2 TDs in a 43–36 overtime loss at Cincinnati.
Ashton Jeanty, 2025 Donruss Downtown! #11
- Before: $702
- Now: $536 (−24%)
- Last week: $451
The Raiders' run game has stalled. Jeanty has run behind one of the league's weakest offensive lines and sits below league average, a long way from the rookie-season expectations that priced his cards.
Bo Nix, 2024 Panini Prizm Silver #309
- Before: $646
- Now: $527 (−18%)
- Last week: $474
The Broncos are winning; Nix's numbers aren't. Denver is 7–2 with five straight wins, but his completion rate and yards per completion are career lows, and he has barely run. That brings up questions about the ankle he broke in last season's playoffs.
Shedeur Sanders, 2025 Donruss Downtown! #17 · Turning?
- Before: $490
- Now: $412 (−16%)
- Last week: $447
He's been the backup to Deshaun Watson, but he started Nov 8 with Watson in the concussion protocol and threw for 297 yards, 2 TDs and no turnovers in a 23–22 overtime loss in New Orleans. Last week's sales are already back above the four-week price, but Watson is back as the starter this week against Houston.
NBA
Kon Knueppel, 2025 Topps Chrome Refractor #254
- Before: $585
- Now: $465 (−21%)
- Last week: $348
He re-injured his hamstring in his season debut on Nov 4 and is expected to miss about four more weeks.
Ja Morant, 2019 Panini Prizm Silver #249
- Before: $292
- Now: $259 (−11%)
- Last week: $210
A new team, then a new injury. Traded to Portland in June, Morant strained his hamstring on Oct 29 in his first game against Memphis. He'll be re-evaluated in late November, though his coach said Nov 7 the injury "might not be as extensive as what we thought."
Giannis Antetokounmpo, 2013 Panini Prizm #290
- Before: $655
- Now: $584 (−11%)
- Last week: $440
The trade to Miami hasn't started well. The Heat are 3–6, and Giannis skipped his media session after the Nov 5 loss to Golden State. He's still averaging 27.3 points and 12.7 rebounds.
MLB
Shohei Ohtani, 2018 Topps Chrome #150 (pitching)
- Before: $1,388
- Now: $966 (−30%)
- Last week: $935
Offseason, after a sweep. The Brewers swept the Dodgers in the NLCS on Oct 16, ending their bid for a third straight title. Ohtani said Milwaukee's pitching left him feeling "exposed."
How we got these numbers: typical PSA 10 sale prices from CardHedger. Before covers Sept 7 to Oct 11 and now covers Oct 12 to Nov 8. 2026 releases are excluded, since new sets drop after release no matter who is on the card. Card images via CardHedger.
Latest from the Calculus
All of the Calculus →

Flippers Lost at November's Fanatics Premier
November 20, 2026
November Premier Follows the Card Market Down to $39.3M as Flipped Cards Bring 24% Less
November 20 auction · 604 lotsCC2 Composite falls 1.8%, its tenth straight weekly decline
November 16, 2026

